Voice of nations.

The UN Herald.

Voice of truth.

The UN Herald.

Voice of fairness.

The UN Herald.

Showing posts with label Member States. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Member States. Show all posts

Sunday, May 19, 2013

Forced migration: Reality vs. simulation

AN INSIGHT INTO THE IMPLEMENTATION

We are slowly coming to an end of the simulation and while we already did an analysis on the adopted resolution against forced migrations and also collected some responses of the delegates right after the GA session, there have been some talks about implementing the resolution. Namely, the US and UK delegations decided to organize an event to prove their determination regarding the implementation of the resolution, and we also received a statement from the representative of South Africa on the current happenings in South Africa regarding the issue of combating forced migrations. What is the potential success of the resolution (or what would it be in real world?). We decided to ask other delegates about their plans regarding the implementation - and about the state of the issue in their countries. Only a minority of delegates responded but nevertheless they provided quite an insight. Due to big differences in dealing with the issue among countries, it is hard to make a thorough review so we recommend that you also read all the interviews below the article.

The states feel that a very good indicator for implemention of the resolution is the fact that it was adopted by consensus. Nigeria is convinced that the consensus only proves the legitimacy of the resolution. But some are also a bit skeptical - we couldn’t put it better than Australia: “After the initial good feelings right after the session, the reality sets in, and we are sure there are countries that might feel a bit hesitant about adopting the whole resolution into their internal law,« said H.E. ms. Mulec. But the overall impression we got from the delegates that responded is that they are quite optimistic. “At the first GA session we saw the political will and we expect States to follow through,” said the UK representative. It could be sensed from other countries as well – they are sure that implementation will take place. H.E. ms. Učakar confirmed this view: “United States of America remain optimistic about the implementation of this resolution. We think that such a broad approach should give States a chance to participate and cooperate on several aspects of the forced migration issue.” Italy stressed there might be some differences in implementation. The resolution consists of three main parts - prevention, protection and burden sharing. “Each state gives preference to one of the three main elements, some states maybe even do not appreciate one part very much, but do support other two, and were therefore willing to support the resolution,” says H.E. ms. Božič. The burden sharing will still be discussed though and Egypt believes “in the success of the upcoming High-Level Dialogue on International Migration and Development, where we will specify the new burden sharing system,” said H.E. ms. Čakić. There is a strong possibility that the resolution will be implemented in different ways in different countries – which is understandable, because countries have different priorities.

When asked about their ways of implementing the resolution, some representatives emphasized that their legal systems already have a certain way of dealing with the issue of forced migrations. “We already have internal legal system that deals with some of the issues mentioned in the resolution,” said Australia. Turkey’s situation is similar – “Turkish law is already in compliance with the spirit of the resolution in many points.” They believe that the situation is not perfect yet in Turkey, although many steps have been taken in order to improve and compensate some injustices that happened in the past. Among those steps is also the implementation of the resolution. Implementation in the USA will also go according to their legal system and already existing policies they have. Both UK and South Korea mentioned that they are proud of some already existing practices of providing a place of refuge for asylum seekers, as they both joined the Convention relating to the Status of Refugees from 1951. Most countries will also try to improve already existing programmes, mechanisms and policies in the light of the adopted resolution. And as Turkey pointed out: “Although we already have legislation regulating the rights of displaced people, we are aware that law by itself cannot change the harsh position they find themselves in,” and we at the UN Herald hope that all countries are aware of this.

Countries specified some of the accomplishments they have already achieved in the area of combating forces migrations. Italy and Turkey, two of the largest recipients of refugees say that they are doing quite a lot. In the area of protection, Italy allocates a lot of money for the protection of displaced persons in Italy and abroad. Another model unprecedented so far is Turkish treatment of Syrian refugees. “We keep the door wide and generously open for our Syrian brothers that are in need of immediate help. There are 17 modern refugee camps throughout the southeast of the country and new are being built, one separate for Syrian Christians. Although it is not their home and cannot compensate it in any case we try to keep standards in refugee camps extremely high - there are televisions, washing machines and people even get weekly pocket money,” said H.E. ms. Jud, representative of Turkey. “Regarding prevention, we already have well established system for fight against SGBV and human trafficking. We do collect, monitor and analyze demographic data and cooperate in the exchange of information,” said H.E. ms. Božič, representative of Italy. Similarly Australia is actively involved in prosecution of intermediaries in illegal smuggling of people. UK and US emphasize their contributions for UNHCR and aid in general. “It is not just about accepting refugees -although that is important - we are also looking abroad to help,” said H.E. ms. Petković, representative of UK.

OPTIMISM - VS. REALISM
To conclude, it seems that countries are quite optimistic regarding the implementation of the resolution – especially because it was adopted by consensus. Would it pass through the real GA? We can only guess. But as it turns out, countries – at least the interviewed ones – are already doing a lot in the area of combating forced migrations. Although some of them already have national legislation that manages the issue of refugees and displaced persons, a resolution or a treaty on an international level seems more than necessary. After all, the issue of forced migrations is becoming more and more difficult for countries to tackle – because of the growing number of refugees and displaced persons and because in reality there is actually no complete document that would settle the status and protection of these persons. National legislations are not enough as countries have their own priorities and put their national interest before the interests of refugees and asylum seekers. Rather than easier, the issue of forced migrations will become even harder to tackle, because of increasing interdependence between countries and because of some new groups of refugees such as environmental refugees etc. So we can only hope that our adopted resolution will provide a wake-up call for countries in the GA.
Tamara Kajtazović 

COMPLETE INTERVIEWS:

1. How does your country perceive the possibility of implementation of the resolution in the international community and in individual member states? (please be specific) 

AUSTRALIA: I think that the resolution has a potential to be implemented in the international community. It is obvious, that it is based on mutual cooperation among delegations, and we are very happy about that. We believe that this is a good starting point for this resolution. However, after the initial good feelings right after the session, the reality sets in, and we are sure there are countries that might feel a bit hesitant about adopting the whole resolution into their internal law. Australia is one of the countries that already has a very good internal legal system when it comes to that matter, but there is always room for improvement.

ITALY: Italy truly hopes that individual member states will implement the resolution, because its implementation in the international community is possible only with full cooperation of all individual states. A good indicator is that resolution on forced migration was adopted with consensus. That shows that all member states of the United Nations are aware of the wide dimensions of the issue of forced migration. However, the problem is that resolution consists of three main parts - prevention, protection and burden sharing. Each state gives preference to one of the three main elements, some states maybe even do not appreciate one part very much, but do support other two, and were therefore willing to support the resolution. Therefore it is most likely to happen that some states will give more attention to one of the elements, and other states to the others, in accordance with their national priorities. For example, states of origin will find more important the protection of their citizens who had to flee, but on the other hand states of destination will find burden sharing and prevention of forced migration more important, since they are facing large income flows of forced migration, which burdens their state, system and citizens.

TURKEY: We believe that the provisions included in the resolution have a great potential that will be carried out with scrupulous performance by the Republic of Turkey and we hope, also by the others. Growing respect of human rights all around the globe have paved the way for more specific provisions against forced migration. Migration, being almost an exclusively international phenomenon, and its regulation therefore, should be tackled in cooperation and with the international support. And that is also the spirit of the accepted resolution. We are looking forward to the 69th General Assembly Session which will determine the specifics of a new burden sharing for the UNHR and meanwhile encourage states for voluntary contributions, cooperate with international as well as national non-governmental organizations to address the issue of Syrian refugees in Turkey and provide them with all needs. In terms with the resolution Turkey will encourage states to increase development aid and thus in a long term lessen the tensions arising from international migration.

SOUTH KOREA: We not just hope, but believe that resolution will be implemented by majority of states who want to protect forced migrants and their rights. Protection of forced migrants is very important, and we hope that also our Asian friends in region will implement resolution very fast, because this issue is spreading very fast and we must act accordingly.

UK: We have been made aware that some parties believe that the resolution against forced migration will not be implemented, or at least not to the extent that would be necessary in order to achieve the change in the protection of displaced and also prevention. We do not agree with such pessimistic stances. On April 25 we saw that GA unanimously accepted the resolution and that speaks volumes. It suggests that the norms included in the resolution are universal and recognized by every state regardless of their political system or special circumstances regarding migration or displacement. At the first GA session we saw the political will and we expect States to follow through.
We do however expect to see more commitment, engagement and cooperation in the area of prevention. Every State has an interest in diminishing the migratory pressures that irregular and extraordinary circumstances generate, this includes persecution, fear of persecution, violence, acts of terrorism, life-threatening catastrophes or devastation or gross violations of human rights and political freedoms. This complements the aspirations of Francis M Deng, the first Representative of the Secretary-General on Internally Displaced Persons who considered it important to tackle the causes of displacement.
However, as pointed out by a study by the United Kingdom Department for International Development even prevention of displacement may be endangered, because they prevention projects or programmes have a long-term-orientation, low visibility and garner little media attention, while relief efforts and providing aid in time of disaster can have quicker, more visible and powerful political results. So risk reduction may not be on every politician's agenda, but here there is space to be innovative, to find new incentives for politicians.
We are particularly worried about IDPs, who are especially vulnerable, since they have not crossed an internationally recognized border and are therefore not protected by international refugee law.

USA: United States of America remain optimistic about the implementation of this resolution. We think that such a broad approach should give States a chance to participate and cooperate on several aspects of the forced migration issue. However, there are several obstacles. We are convinced that each country should work according to the approach of prevention and protection. The session showed that countries are interested and committed to resolving the issue. It is of course crucial to establish international and regional mechanisms. We are certain that USA will continue to work with the  Latin America region, European Union and Asia-Pacific on the regional basis. We will continue to be involved on the international level through the UN, ICRC and IOM. We see this resolution as a step forward and a confirmation of states' involvement in the issue and their aim to resolve its various aspects.

2. How should the implementation be carried out in your country? (please be specific) 

AUSTRALIA: As we already stated, we already have internal legal system that deals with some of the issues mentioned in the resolution. As for the rest, we always were and will continue to be a country that supports further negotiation and help with implementation (since resolution is also dealing with some issues that will need further negotiation)

ITALY: Firstly, we already started with special governmental meetings regarding implementation of the resolution on forced migration and we are planning many more of them. We have to make a clear strategy  how to fully implement the resolution. At our first meeting we already defined our goals - strengthening our role in burden sharing system, which concretely means that we'll increase donations to UNHCR; becoming more involved in the process of prevention of forced migration through international cooperation; strengthening the protection of displaced persons, internally and abroad. Secondly, we are going to actively participate at the upcoming session of the second committee of the General Assembly in its sixty-ninth session, and encourage adoption of more concrete measures, which will be realizable also in our country.

SOUTH KOREA: Republic of Korea does not have many forced migrants. We accept forced migrants from North Korea and from Africa. We joined Convention relating to the Status of Refugees in 1992 and recognised first refugee in 2011, and we will certainly implement resolution accepted at the GA session. We grant refugee status to those whose life is threatened by political, religious and other forms of persecution. We are improving our system regarding forced migrants. Also every year we give more money to United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees and we believe in strengthening it’s position. Over the last year, the government continued law enforcement efforts against sex trafficking which is big issue in our state. We believe that we will fulfil duties from accepted resolution.

TURKEY: We believe that the situation is not perfect yet in Turkey, although many steps have been taken in order to improve and compensate some injustices that happened in the past. The implementation of the resolution will definitely be one of those steps, which will make us also one step closer to the European Union. Although we already have legislation regulating the rights of displaced people, we are aware that law by itself cannot change the harsh position they find themselves in. With the launched peace process and truce with the PKK we anticipate lower tensions in the society against displaced of Kurdish origin. The new constitution that is being prepares be the Commission for Constitutional Agreement is also working in this way.

UK: The UK is proud of its tradition of providing a place of refuge for genuine asylum seekers, so individuals who are fleeing persecution in their own country and are unable to go back due to a well-founded fear of persecution as stipulated in the 1951 United Nations Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees. We comply with the provisions of the European Convention on Human Rights, including not sending individuals to a country, where there is a threat that they will be tortured, or face inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. We even provide some individuals with temporary permission to stay in the UK for humanitarian reasons.  UK is one of the largest recipients of refugees. in 2012, we accepted 27,400 applicants as refugees, making it the 5th largers recipient in the group of 44 industrialized countries. The numbers increased since 2011, when we accepted 25,900 claims, mainly because of the increase in asylum seekers from Pakistan and the Syrian Arab Republic. In terms of GDP per capita, we are also the 5th most generous State when it comes to positive responses to refugee claims.

USA: Implementation in our country will go according to our legal system and of course, already existing policies we have. United States of America remain committed to address these topics through UNHCR, other relevant multilateral and bilateral forums as well as the UN in general. United States will try to improve already existing programmes, mechanisms and policies. Furthermore, our country will continue to cooperate, discuss and negotiate with other countries in order to properly develop our own programmes and especially homogenize on the issues of common interest, such as displacement of persons due to conflicts and human trafficking and smuggling. We shall especially try to continue on our work on protecting victims, enable them to get proper care and rehabilitation. United States are convinced that some of the provisions are already being implemented in our own country.

3. Is your country maybe already carrying out some actions that are contributing to the implementation of the resolution? 

AUSTRALIA: We are actively involved in prosecution of intermediaries in illegal smuggling of people, we support burden sharing and cooperate with UN and other agencies that are involved with this issue.

ITALY: Italy is already carrying out some actions that are contributing to the implementation of the resolution. Regarding prevention, we already have well established system for fight against SGBV and human trafficking. We do collect, monitor and analyze demographic data and cooperate in the exchange of information. We are also planning the adoption of legislation, measures and strategies which will help prevent displacement. Regarding protection, we do allocate a lot of money for the protection of displaced persons in Italy and abroad. We are directing our development aid and assistance to conflict zones in order to help people and to rebuild home communities. For example, we are sending humanitarian and financial aid to Syria. Italy is the second European donor for 2013, with 22 million euros earmarked in addition to the 7.5 million allocated thus far. We are also sending tons and tons of essential supplies, such as food, medical kits, etc. We also donated a lot of money to Libya, Yemen, Georgia, etc. Furthermore, we are a destination state of many displaced persons, and we are trying to protect them as much as possible. We know there is still a lot of space for improvement, and we are working on that. We are fully aware that ALL people have to be entitled their basic human rights and fundamental freedoms, and are aware of the seriousness of the forced migration. Regarding burden sharing, Italy is one of the states, which already contribute to UNHCR. We contribute almost 10 million dollars every year, and that stands us on the 19th place on the list of donors. We are willing to contribute more money next year, in order to further strengthen the burden-sharing system. We also appeal to all the countries that do not contribute anything to the UNHCR's fund yet (2/3 of member states of the UN), to start contributing, because only with cooperation of all states we will be able to prevent forced migration and protect displaced persons. We believe a lot has to be done in order to fully implement the resolution, but we will do our best.
SOUTH KOREA: As mentioned in previous lines, our state is already carrying out activities and we will certainly inform you when we will finish with implementation of resolution.
TURKEY: Turkish law is already in compliance with the spirit of the resolution in many points. In recent years we have developed series of laws and policies to address the situation of displaced people, in April this year we adopted new act regulating the status and rights of Syrian refuges in Turkey. Furthermore we promote cooperation of international as well as national nongovernmental organizations when addressing the issue of refugees and increase our official development aid and humanitarian assistance every year.
Firstly, Turkey is running Return to villages and rehabilitation programme since 1994 which encompasses the restoration of villages that suffered from terrorist attacks in the past and thus enables the safe return of displaced persons. Moreover, the programme offers them special rehabilitation treatment for displaced people and guarantees their equal treatment. The great success was made in 2006 when the Law on Compensation of Losses Resulting from Terrorist Acts and the Measures Taken against Terrorism was passed. Compensating economic losses of the victims it catalyzes solidarity within nation and makes Turkey one of the few states that offer compensations for people suffering from internal displacement and could be a role model for other states that should also address the same issue. 
Secondly, another model unprecedented so far is Turkish treatment of Syrian refugees. We keep the door wide and generously open for our Syrian brothers that are in need of immediate help. There are 17 modern refugee camps throughout the southeast of the country and new are being built, one separate for Syrian Christians. Although it is not their home and cannot compensate it in any case we try to keep standards in refugee camps extremely high - there are televisions, washing machines and people even get weekly pocket money. Staff have provided much needed support to the most vulnerable Syrians. Camp residents have enough to eat, there are child-friendly spaces and educational programs, and there are dedicated areas for women to gather and get help. However, as the capacity of camps is low regarding the increasing inflow of refugees, we allow the ones with passports to live even outside the camps and rent houses, and offers the free health care.

UK: It is not just about accepting refugees -although that is important - we are also looking abroad to help. The UK aid abroad aimed at prevention and protection is huge, but hard to assess, particularly the development aid that indirectly prevents displacements and is carried out or handled by our Department of International Development. Development strategies vary and they focus on a variety of fields: promotion of human rights, rule of law, democracy. We also see exchange of information, expertise and know-how in different government, public policy, scientific and technical fields as extremely important. It is also heavily involved in sustainable development and combating climate change. It focuses on gender issues in development and conflict. We also think it is crucial that we support businesses to help them break in to new regional and international markets to boost economic growth. We did this in the Occupied Palestinian Territories.
We are also active abroad to strengthen protection of refugees and displaced people. We have donated £139.5 million in humanitarian funding to help Syrian refugees and provide them with support (food, shelter, medical care, safe and clean drinking water) both in Syria and in neighboring refugee camps. We are also committed to helping refugees fleeing the conflict in Democratic Republic of Congo and have been providing health care, education, shelter and safe drinking water for 50,000 refugees in Uganda. We are also involved in helping refugees in South Sudan, and have already sent assistance packages to support Somali refugees in Kenya and Ethiopia, as well as forced migrants in Burma. All these efforts and emergency assistance is supposed to help the UNHCR and make sure that it operates effectively and continuously.
Besides providing material and financial resources we are also actively and diplomatically searching for peaceful resolution of conflict in different regions as a strategy for ending or minimizing refugee flows.
We work on all these fronts, because we recognize that there are many different contributing factors to displacement. It is important to adopt a holistic approach.

USA: United States are doing their best to contribute to the proper reolution of the issue of forced migration. We have been working extensively on the field and through multilateral forums previously mentioned. Furthemore, we have been the biggest contributor to the UN system in general and UNHCR and UNGIFT in particular. We have several internal policies that spread beyond our borders - such as the work of our agencies, for example USAID, United States President's Interagency Task Force, US Foreign Assitance Resources and several programmes such as those in protracted areas etc. USA has given 28 commemorated pledges, addressing five themes ranging from asylum and detention, to vulnerable populations, to refugee resettlement and statelessness.

EGYPT’S STATEMENT
As one of the sponsors of the later adopted Resolution we firstly wrote and then proposed it with a strong belief and hope that states will of course support the resolution, but more than just that, our highest hope as well as faith in the international community was and still is that provisions of the Resolution will also be implemented. Without implementation all our work and efforts to improve the protection of forced migrants were in vain.
We believe that the international community already showed intention to provide greater protection of the forced migrants, especially the most vulnerable among them, with supporting the UNHCR and with bilateral and multilateral assistance to the affected countries and regions. Taking into account the voting outcome at the GA Session on the 25 April, we have even higher expectations from countries and do believe in implementation of the provisions we all agreed upon.
Firstly, Egypt hopes that states that have not contributed to the UNHCR yet will change their attitude and take responsibility for the global challenge of forced migrants and hence provide the needed protection of this vulnerable group. Secondly, we believe in the success of the upcoming High-Level Dialogue on International Migration and Development, where we will specify the new burden sharing system. Meanwhile, we call upon states to provide protection for IDPs, refugees, victims of human trafficking and all the other people affected by violence or other threatening situations that force them to flee their homes. Egypt also calls upon states to stop violent conflicts and aggression against the innocent civilians, with additional emphasis on preventing further suffering of our brothers and sisters in Syria and Palestine and all the other states.
Egypt will continue providing shelter and protection for forced migrants in close cooperation with the UNHCR and will fight against human trafficking and continue to put efforts in supporting and assisting states in peaceful settlement of disputes and conflicts that contribute to the increasing number of forced migrants. As a state with very positive and effective cooperation with the UNHCR we will continue our practice and hence continue implementation of the provisions of the adopted Resolution as we were already doing before the adoption. Our cooperation with the UNHCR and efforts in protection of forced migrants as well as of the victims of human trafficking served as an inspiration and motivation for contributing to the Resolution against Forced Migration and encouraging other states to do the same and protect the vulnerable, not only in words, but also and especially in practice.

NIGERIA'S STATEMENT
Nigeria is very pleased to notice the global awareness about the forced migrants issue. Resolution was adopted by consensus, proving its legitimacy. Overall it sucesfully adresses the global forced migrations issue, and also focuses on the general African region.
Recognition of the regional African forced migrations issues from the preamble, noting 5 of the 8 crisis zones taking place in Africa, recognition of the regional organisations in adressing the problem in the clauses 28 and 29, recognition of developmental differences and heavier burdens experienced by states, affected by forced migrations caused by crisis zones and reinforcing the UNHCR with the burden-sharing system in clauses 34 and 36, sends promising signals to the africans.
Nigeria is grateful, that it doesnt suffer much from conflicts and other issues, resulting in forced migrations, but is very pleased, that this resolution will help suffering forced migrants from our region on a path into a better life. We, Nigerians, are already deeply involved in spreading peace and security in the region. This new resolution is of great help to our cause.
Nigeria congratulates all the countries on this new tool for enabling the forced migrants more rights and means for a decent life.

Thursday, May 9, 2013

Delegates during an Unmoderated Caucus

In the first video you can watch the delegate of Russian Federation, who reminds the world on the anniversary of the Great Patriotic war in the Soviet Union and comments the simulation.

In the second video we catch the delegates of the USA, Italy and China



Wednesday, May 8, 2013

Separate positions - same goals: Asia-Pacific group


Six out of ten most populous countries in the world are located in the region of the Asia-Pacific that boasts a breathtaking ethnic and religious diversity.
 The biggest threat to the rights of ethnic and religious minorities in the world's most populous country, China, is its mix of authoritarian government, Han nationalism and rapid development. Minorities are strictly defined by Beijing, and some groups, especially those from resource rich areas, remain unrecognized. The Indonesian government, dominated by the Javanese and infamous for its corruption during the three decades under General Suharto, has been oppressive towards ethnic and religious minority groups in Indonesia. Ethnic and sectarian tensions have been exploited by the military in order to maintain influence and prevent close examination of past human rights abuses. 8% of the population in Australia consists of Asian and Muslim communities. They have faced harassment and are subject to the recent government emphasis on "Australian-ness". In India, the rights of many minorities have not been secured, despite a certain level of legal protection. Both low-caste Dalits ("Untouchables") and diverse indigenous tribal peoples (Adivasis) suffer pervasive marginalization within the Hindu majority (MRG 2013).
In order to research the issue of the treatment of minorities in this region we asked the delegates to answer a few questions. Cooperation of the states of the Asian-Pacific told us the last time in their joint statement that they believe in diversity and respect of human rights and at the same time thy were of the opinion that minority issues should stay the question of the internal affairs of the each state. This was repeated one more time today. Ms Maša Tiselj, the representative of India stated: "We agree that promotion of diversity and protection of human rights are crucial however we discovered that we have very different ideas on specific approaches and that common position would not be possible, so on Thursday no specific joint efforts of the Asia-Pacific region can be expected". 

The representative of Indonesia Ms Tina Orešnik came to the same conclusion: "The Asian - Pacific group has a large diapazon of mutual interests, and tackling the problems, that stem from the issue of minorities is certainly one of them. Yet, we also agree that we are countries, that are very different -  in terms of developmental, ethnical, cultural, political and even more generally speaking - societal profile. Therefore, it would be highly unreasonable to commit to a variety of declaratory goals, that would then prove to be difficult or even impossible to achieve in terms of the aforementioned differences. So each country will deal with the issues individually. Indonesia is, however, willing to offer any kind of help that is at our disposal should the need for this be expressed by (a) member state(s)."

The point of my interest was also whether the states of the Asia-Pacific agree with the main ideas and strategies of the WP proposed by UK, South Africa and India?
To sum up, you will that some countries have separate positions on the content of the WP as some parts may are not in accordance with their agenda.
China: 
"To be honest, when we got the WP on the issue of minorities, the first thing that surprised us, was a quite diverse group of states which are on the list of sponsors or signatories. Because of that we were sceptical from the very start what this kind of resolution could bring about. People's Republic of China sees this document pretty incoherent and in spots contradictory. Nevertheless, we do not like to comment on this WP more in detail. China is looking forward to the discussion and we are hoping that ambiguities and doubts will be explained and solved there successfully." 
South Korea: 

"Republic of Korea is a big advocate of human rights and believes in protecting in minorities. We support resolution and we are also the signatory of the resolution. We agree with clause “"condemn terrorist and extremist actions that are motivated by religious, ethnic, racial or any other hatred", besides they also asked the Human Rights Council to". As it was mentioned in the interview, Republic of Korea also supports intra-state controlling mechanisms, and even more, we support work of not just UN, but also regional organisations, which can contribute a lot to this topic. Overall, Republic of Korea agrees with preposed resolution and believes it is a very good one."

Indonesia: 

"Indonesia firmly believes in the good and noble intentions of the WP our distinguished fellow delegates have prepaired. Yet, we must be very careful when approaching such a resolution, both in term of understanding it properly, as well as positioning oneself either in a supporting or opposing position. It is crucial, that such a delicate issue as the minorities certainly are, is dealt with very carefully. There are certain points in the WP that should not be a point of dispute for none of the member states, for example the protection of human rights, striving towards a peaceful and inclusive multicultural society, etc. It is also important to appreciate the effort that has been put into it. There are some points though, that are not completely atuned with the general guidelines of our state and foreign policy, but this was to be expected, taking into consideration the differences between the countries as such"

Australia:
"Australia appreciates the effort UK, South Africa and India made when drafting the WP. As a signatory of this WP, we are, of course, very supportive about it."

We also asked the representative if they could point out some approaches their states are using in order to manage the issue of the minorities, and which could be translated all over the world? States are mostly convinced that the same (special) mechanism can not be applied universally, even though it can be said that equality among population is a path to solution.

India: 

"We believe that it is impossible to translate one specific approach all over the world because "the issue of minorities" differs from state to state, however we encourage the exchange of good practices among states. In general any approach that respects human rights, non-discrimination and promotes inter-cultural dialogue is a good approach. In India we are very proud of our multicultural, multi-linguistic and multi-religious heritage most of which is the consequence of many different minorities groups that live in our country which is why we want to ensure their upliftment. What you may find interesting about our country is that we aim to improve socioeconomic conditions of our minorities through inclusive development and even through affirmative action. We are well aware of the fact that there had been a wide disparity in the social and educational status of different sections of a largely caste-based and tradition-bound society in the past. Therefore our Constitution permits positive discrimination in favour of the weak, the disadvantaged and the backward so that they can have the same starting point as other citizens and thus equal opportunities for active participation in the building of our vibrant nation. Our Constitution admits discrimination with reasons but prohibits discrimination without reason.
To ensure that protection of minorities in our constitution is also implemented we have established a Ministry of Minority Affairs as well as a number of other institutions such as National Commission for Minorities, National Commission for Scheduled Castes, National Commission for Backward Classes etc. We believe that we are doing a great job and progress can be seen especially in the areas of education, employment, infrastructural development, and also in the prevention and control of communal disharmony and violence."
South Korea:
"Republic of Korea does a lot of work on this field. Even though we are homogenous state, a significant A significant step towards concentrating on human rights protection was the signing of South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation Social Charter in 2004. This instrument contains 21 objectives and some of these objectives have direct bearing on protection of minorities. Republic of Korea is also party of all treaties that protect human rights and also minorities. Even though that in past Korea’s attitudes of Koreans toward foreigners were often thought to be ethnocentric, citizens of South Korea are tolerant and open toward foreigners and immigrants living in our state."
China:
"People’s Republic of China does not believe in templates, which could be used all around the world in all cultures, political systems etc. Therefore we do not wish to impose our approach to this issue on any other country. China is a united multi-ethnic state with developed system of regional autonomy and legislation which protects all ethic minorities’ rights on all levels. This system really does work in China and this is the most important thing."
Indonesia:
"Although Indonesia is the largest Islamic state in the world, we try to be as considerate as possible when it comes to othe religions as well. An example of this migh seem not important at a first glance, but sends a rather powerful message about the importance of respecting all religions equally. Namely, despite being the country with the world's largest Muslim population, Protestantism and Catholicism are among the six officially recognized religions - along with Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, and Confucianism. All these religions' major religious holidays are national public holidays. This systemic approach - treating different minorities equally in all and every aspect of life - is what Indonesia believes is the right way to a sociaty of equality"

Australia:
"Australia has quite a difficult past when it comes to minorities. However, we have dealt with our past and are now very actively involved with our minority groups and making sure their rights are implemented. One way of doing that are centres that offer education, health service etc and are some sort of connection between the government and minorities. They are led either by the members of minority groups of government officials. Also, we are encouraging minority groups and others to be a part of programmes aimed at integration of minority members into society as equal members. We believe that if we are educated about each other’s cultures and habits, we will be able to accept each other better."
Reference:
MRG. 2013. World Directory for Minorities and Indigenous Peoples: Overview of Asia and Oceania. Available at: http://www.minorityrights.org/?lid=499 

Tuesday, May 7, 2013

Brighter future for forced migrants

Our mailbox has been filling up with e-mails from representatives about their intention to implement the resolution against forced migrations.We have already reported about UK ans US's initiative to organize a fundraising event and now we received a statement from H.E. ms Juričić, representative of South Africa. We strongly encourage other delegates to think about implementation in their countries and about ways that the they themselves could contribute to the implementation.

H.E. ms. Jurčić reported that her country started to carry out some actions that will contribute to implementing the resolution and protection of forced migrants, namely they have deployed more immigration officers at the Beitbridge Border Post to solve the volatile situation caused by increased human traffic at the country’s busiest point of entry. Human trafficking was definitely an issue that most of the countries identified as a very important in the light of combating forced migrations and the resolution also included quite some clauses on the topic.

See the full statement below:

SOUTH AFRICAN STATEMENT ON FORCED MIGRATION AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOLUTION

 South Africa has already commended the representatives of other states for adopting the Resolution against Forced Migration on 25 April on Twitter, but wants to do it now more officially. We firmly believe that the adopted document marks a milestone in the global fight against forced migration – both against its causes, as well as its consequences.

South Africa is especially happy that regional organisations have been encouraged to cooperate more strongly with the UNHCR and that their preventive measures and protection of displaced people should be strengthened. Furthermore, it is of extreme importance that the issue of human trafficking is included. It is significant not only on the global level, but also for our country, since human trafficking to South Africa is increasing and a lot of children and women are sexually exploited. At this point, we want to emphasise that we have already started implementing the resolution. In the spirit of the provisions, South Africa has deployed more immigration officers at the Beitbridge Border Post to solve the volatile situation caused by increased human traffic at the country’s busiest point of entry. This has been decided by our Home Affairs co-Minister Kembo Mohadi and by his Zimbabwean counterpart Mrs Naledi Pandor in order to end the chaos at the border. Mess at the border opens up easier ways for human traffickers and smugglers due to lessened control. More immigration officers and more clearance points will therefore ensure better control and hopefully more effective prevention of human trafficking and smuggling.

Saturday, May 4, 2013

Steps toward a new beginning - USA and Cuba

The representative of the USA, Ms Urška Učakar and the delegate of the Cuba, Ms Mojca Ferme pleasantly surprised our editorial today with the official written statements where they showed the will to turn a new page in USA-Cuban relationship. 

Tense relations between USA and Cuba lasts since Cold War. The root cause was of ideological nature - USA wanted the Cuban government to move toward democratization and respect for human rights, while on the other hand Havana with the rule of Communist regime had a very close relationship with Moscow. President of the USA Kennedy and his administration were deeply concerned about such close relations and Cuban regime. Therefore the United States has in 1962 imposed an economic embargo against Cuba. 

Fifty years later, the embargo has not achieved the most important goal - to overthrow the Communist regime which continues to control Cuba, while most vulnerable residents pay the highest price. Moreover Cuban government said that embargo costed the state over 700 billion euros. 

In November 2012 United nations General Assembly voted with the vast majority to condemn the USA embargo against Cuba - 186 UN member states opposed to sanctions and assessed as unnecessary, while only USA, Israel and Palau were against the resolution.

Step forward was made in 2011, when US President Barack Obama used his executive powers and lifted some restrictions, such as travel restrictions for educational and cultural groups. As 1.5 million members of the Cuban diaspora live in the USA, Obama has allowed them to send remittances to Cuba.

After five decades, in July 2012, the Cuba has received first shipment of humanitarian aid, which has arrived from Miami. This action has been positively accepted by the Cuban community in Florida, but there was no response from the government. 

Each relationship has its limits  so does USA- Cuban. US contractor Alan Gross was arrested in Cuba in 2009 for distributing laptops and communication equipment to members of Cuba's small Jewish community. Ms. Učakar was very clear in her letter regarding the case of Mr. Gross and USA-Cuban relations. Her statement was conditionally made - meaning if Cuba release Ms. Gross USA will be prepared to negotiate on lifting the embargo. 

The UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention is making the effort to solve the case of Mr. Gross. Even though the Working Group has no enforcement powers, the ruling could put pressure on the Cuban government in order to release Mr. Gross. In December 2012 the report of the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention has been released.


Below you can read the official statements of both states:

USA


"As Obama administration has already announced in 2008, United States of America are certain that a series of changes in U.S. policy to reach out to the Cuban people can help support their desire to freely determine their country’s future. In taking these steps to help bridge the gap among divided Cuban families and promote the freer flow of information and humanitarian items to the Cuban people, President Obama is working to fulfill the goals he identified both during his presidential campaign and since taking office. This administration has done its best to lift all restrictions on transactions related to the travel of family members, improve communication infrastructure and enable flow of humanitarian items.
United States of America fully support decisions of international bodies and we are committed to goals and principles of the international community. Therefore, we warmly welcome the decision of the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention which has decided that detention of Mr. Alan Phillip Gross is arbitrary. We urge Cuba to release Mr. Gross without any preconditions.
We remain committed to policies that support the welfare of the Cuban people, despite the arrest and continued detention of Alan Gross, a 63-year-old American citizen who was sentenced to 15 years in prison for facilitating Internet access for Cuba's small Jewish community. The United States again calls on Cuba to immediately release Mr. Gross.
The United States strongly supports the desire of the Cuban people to freely determine their own future. With other Member States, the United States determines its conduct of economic relationships with other countries in accordance with its national interests and principles. Our sanctions policy toward Cuba is just one of the tools in our overall effort to encourage respect for the human rights and basic freedoms to which the United Nations itself is committed.
Release of Mr. Gross and reconsideration of other similar detentions would be a sign that Cuba believes in human rights, equality and respect for every human being. In this respect, United States of America would be prepared to participate in negotiations on the annual resolution of the UN addressed Necessity of ending the economic, commercial and financial embargo imposed by the United States of America against Cuba.

Urška Učakar
Permanent Representative of the United States of America to the United Nations"



Cuba

"Cuba maintains a high level of cooperation and interaction with the procedures and mechanisms of the United Nations system in the area of human rights and has a positive dialogue with the bodies created by the international treaties on human rights. To demonstrate we are serious, we would like to show we fully respect Working Group on Arbitrary Detention. Cuba has already, in the spirit of transparency and cooperation, provided to the Working Group extensive information on the Mr. Alan Philip Gross case to enable it to assess it objectively. Since Cuba has always expressed its willingness to establish a dialogue on every issue and with all States on the basis of mutual respect, sovereign equality, and the recognition of the right to self-determination, we are also willing to establish this kind of dialogue with the United States. We are open to a constructive and respectful dialogue, based on the truth. Therefore, we invite Obama administration to meet Cuba at the negotiating table to solve bilateral issues between the two states and to discuss the release of Mr. Alan Phillip Gross in exchange of starting the talks about the issue of embargo. It is time to start building better relations based on cooperation and respect."

***

References: 


ABCNews. 2012. UN Report Calls on Cuba to Release American. Available at: http://abcnews.go.com/m/story?id=18162770&sid=81

AFP. 2013. Record vote for UN resolution against Cuba embargo. Available at: http://www.google.com/hostednews/afp/article/ALeqM5jQcE0-rilpTdqNTE-6xr0lP0DRaw?docId=CNG.169e2b06165bc926eb8e2209eb58d48b.f1

AlJazeera. 2012. Cuba receives first US shipment in 50 years. Available at: http://www.aljazeera.com/news/americas/2012/07/20127147196482238.html

The Guardian. 2011. Barack Obama acts to ease US embargo on Cuba. Available at: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/jan/15/barack-obama-us-embargo-cuba